-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 140
Open
Labels
info-neededIssue requires more information from posterIssue requires more information from poster
Description
Subject: Usability issues — verbosity handling and execution policy
Summary
- Issue A (verbosity): The assistant repeatedly ignored explicit user instructions to produce concise/minimal outputs and continued producing verbose progress reports.
- Issue B (execution policy): The assistant executed environment-specific commands (for example
git) without verifying applicability to the current workspace.
Impact
- Both behaviors reduce trust and efficiency: verbosity wastes review time; unverified environment actions can fail or cause side effects.
Repro steps (high level)
- Ask for concise output (e.g., "Stop the verbose explanations and just produce the finished product.").
- Observe assistant continues verbose multi-step outputs.
- Observe assistant attempting environment actions without confirming context (e.g., running
git commitin a folder that isn't a git repo).
User preference / consent
- The user does consent to automatic execution when applicable and verified. They prefer:
- Automatic execution of relevant commands that progress toward the final outcome.
- No execution of non-applicable commands (the assistant must verify applicability first).
- No unprompted execution of commands outside the requested scope.
Requested fixes
- Honor an explicit session-level verbosity preference until revoked.
- Require the assistant to verify applicability before running environment commands, and obtain confirmation when unsure.
- Provide a strict "minimal mode" that returns only essential results (file edits or a one-line confirmation).
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
info-neededIssue requires more information from posterIssue requires more information from poster